So, my adored Swobo woolens are starting to fray. I did some research and picked up a pair of Bicycle Fixation Classic Wool Knickers (link) and a pair of Swrve Winter Softshell Knickers (link). Both at the same (steep) price point of $125. I'm going to ride them all winter and tell you all what I think.
Right off the bat, however, I can tell these two are apples and oranges. The BF knicks are like suit pants, and the Swrve knicks are like body armor. Very different heft and robustness. The Swrve knicks are tanks. First blush, the Swrve's are a lot better constructed. The BF knicks are constructed well, but seem like they were made by a competent amateur seamster. The Swrve's are clearly a professional job. For the same price, the Swrve's are (out of the packaging) clearly in the lead.